Sometimes I want to ask that question. Or "Why not me?".
I just read the district newsletter. It was full of wonderful articles about people doing things and how wonderfully they worked for them. I am delighted that they have captured success.
I read an article about a pastor who began to read through the Bible with his wife. Suddenly, he had a Bible study with thirty people attending! Two Bible studies, actually. I am happy for him. I have been reading the Bible for decades. My Bible classes are basically reading through the Bible, sometimes with commentary, and answering questions. My Bible studies have shrunk, not grown. Mind you, most everyone who attends tells me how wonderful they think they are! I have had people leave my congregation for a different local congregation telling me how terrific I am, and that I ought to be the pastor of a large congregation, so that my talent will benefit even more people - as they are on their way out the door! Why doesn't it work for me?
I am not complaining. No, really! I know why the things that are happening are happening. God works in His own way and at His own time. I have been doing the same things for decades, and have had varying "success" at different times. I just find it frustrating to read all the 'how to' articles and the 'we did it this way' testimonials, which all suggest or say outright that if you are creative and clever like them and do things the right way, you will be amazed at the results.
I understand that God works in His own way and at His own time. I would love to have different results, but I would love even more if people in the church stopped acting as though it is their creativity and their effort that makes things work the way they work. I have figured out that God grants the prosperity we enjoy, whatever that prosperity may be (actually, the Bible teaches that principle). I just worry that someone who hasn't figured that out might actually take those theology of glory kind of messages to heart and be beaten-up by the sense of failure that accompanies doing all the right things - things others are boasting about making them so successful - and finding their results are not all that impressive.
Limited sucess is hard enough to handle without those who ought to know better preaching to you that the right program or technique is all you need.
When will the church get back to living out and living in her own theology?